Sports, Queer Lives and Figure Skating

(Photo: Jayna Ledford demonstrates the hard work, athleticism, precision, beauty and discipline of ballet, which is NOT a sport and has NOT banned her from stages worldwide because of who she is)

A sport is a social system in which participants (athletes) voluntarily submit to a hierarchical, authoritarian system that governs what they can and cannot do with their own body, based on someone else’s ideals related to gender, race, sexuality and social class. It is definitionally the opposite of bodily autonomy. And as we have seen over the last year, politicians who have nothing to do with any particular sport wield immense power over who does and does not belong: sports are inextricably tied up with government and hence politics.

The explicit exclusion of trans athletes we see today amongst the broader Trans Panic reflects present and past exclusion of athletes of the wrong ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, social class or even academic abilities (see “jocks vs nerds”). Sports have never been welcoming, and in their “us vs them / domination” mentality they manage to bring out the worst in people.

Figure skating is unique among sports in that it is not intrinsically a sport: it only became a sport because people of a certain social class and gender WANTED it to be a sport. From the beginning they systematically excluded people different from themselves through explicit and implicit rules, and in fact actively put down other ways of skating in their official magazine. On can argue that today’s “beer league” adult figure skating functions more as a platform for community and expression: the emphasis on costumes, music and performance, and overall attitude of participants, is more typical of a dance recital than a sports competition. But for whatever reason, this social activity has chosen to associate with a sports governing body, one with a long history of actively working against the inclusion, expression and bodily autonomy that figure skating could otherwise achieve — all in the name of sports, of course. “Fairness” is and always has been a fig leaf for control of others’ bodies.

As long as queer bodies are considered suspect by society at large, sports will reflect that. Thus, a transgender sports participant can NEVER be “just like everybody else except for this one thing at birth.” I understand the sports environment has shifted radically in the last few years, and I feel bad for people how have invested years of their life, only to have the rug pulled out from under them. But for any trans girl today, I would not recommend trying to join any sport. There are better social structures to engage in, social structures that strive for athletic excellence, celebrate humanity in all its forms and actively nurture independence, maturity and bodily autonomy… social structures queer people are WANTED. These communities are of course not as visible or well funded as sports. But in exchange they are ignored by politicians; hence they operate in an environment of full freedom, bodily autnonmy and First Amendment rights. That is a good thing.

I would make the same recommendation, in fact, for any queer person: the forced conformity of sports to idealized norms is fundamentally incompatible with queer identity. Live your life, express yourself. It’s YOUR body.

Bibliography:

  • Jessie Gender made a YouTube essay exploring the nature of sports in-depth, from the perspective of someone who had never been involved herself: Why Liberals Keep Losing the Trans Sports Debate
  • Erica Rand is a queer participant in the Adult Figure Skating competition circuit in the United States. She has written more than two books, in which she explores (among other things) the ways in which figure skating competitions serve as a vehicle for community and self expression, and queer participation in figure skating.